Are we still in the Iron Age?

Published on Author Mark Erickson12 Comments

There are very few references to iron (σιδηρος) in Homer: this is the Bronze Age after all, or rather a tale of the Bronze Age. When reference is made to iron these note firstly the difficulties in working it and then the value of this new metal. The value is shown in, for example, Achilles choosing lumps of iron as prizes in the funeral games he held for Patroklus (Iliad Chapter 23, esp. 826-35).

Homer was writing at the start of the Iron Age, according to generally accepted archaeological schemes. Would Homer know this? Perhaps. Hesiod, a writer roughly contemporary to Homer, wrote in Work and Days a history of the world up to that time: it was divided into five ‘ages’ – Gold, Silver, Bronze, Heroic (the time of the battle of Troy), and finally Iron, his own time. Our current archaeological three-age system – Stone Age, Bronze Age, Iron Age – ends in the same place, and suggests that we haven’t yet left the iron age.

Maybe we are still Iron Age people? Max Weber, after all, characterised our time with reference to iron. I was reviewing a journal article a few days ago: it made repeated references to Max Weber’s ‘iron cage of modernity’ and I felt I had to point out in my review the error of this formulation (the paper was, by the way, about aspects of Weber’s work). Weber never used the phrase ‘iron cage of modernity’. I think that the article’s author was ‘paraphrasing’ from The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (Weber 1904) where Talcott Parsons, who translated the text into English in 1930, puts the words ‘iron cage’ into Weber’s mouth (rather than using the direct translation of stahlhartes Gehäuse (‘steel-hard casing’):

“In Baxter’s view the care for external goods should only lie on the shoulders of the ‘saint like a light cloak, which can be thrown aside at any moment’. But fate decreed that the cloak should become an iron cage.” (Weber 1958: 181)

Parsons had, arguably, good reasons for doing this as it is a reference to Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress, and actually Weber does use the phrase ‘iron cage’ somewhere else in his work. But not in The Protestant Ethic!

Hannah Arendt also used an iron metaphor in The Human Condition (1959), one that, I think, is deliberately referencing Weber. This is in her conclusion to the book:

“It is quite conceivable that the modern age – which began with such an unprecedented and promising outburst of human activity – may end in the deadliest, most sterile passivity history has ever known. But there are other more serious danger signs that man may be willing and, indeed, is on the point of developing into that animal species from which, since Darwin, he imagines he has come. … [it] becomes manifest that all his activities, watched from a sufficiently removed vantage pint in the universe, would appear not as activities of any kind but as processes, so that, as a scientist recently put it, modern motorization would appear like a process of biological mutation in which human bodies gradually begin to be covered by shells of steel. For the watcher from the universe, this mutation would be no more or less mysterious than the mutation which now goes on before our eyes in those small living organisms which we fought with antibiotics and which mysteriously developed new strains to resist us.” (295)

Prescient stuff from Arendt: consumerism, passivity and antiobiotic resistance – all things that we need to act against.

Are we still in the Iron Age? Hannah Landecker, who quotes Arendt in her excellent paper ‘Antibiotic Resistance and the Biology of History’ (2016), proposes that the widespread use of antibiotics from the mid-20th century onwards has so fundamentally altered human-nature relations and the environment around us that it can be considered to be the start of what we now call the Anthropocene.

 

References

Arendt, H. (1959) The Human Condition, New York: Doubleday.

Hesiod and Most, G.W. (2006) Hesiod, Cambridge, Mass. ; London: Harvard University Press.

Homer, Murray, A.T. and Wyatt, W.F. (1999) Iliad, Cambridge, Mass. ; London: Harvard University Press.

Landecker, H. (2016) ‘Antibiotic Resistance and the Biology of History’, Body & Society, 22, 4, 19-52.

Weber, M. (1958) The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

12 Responses to Are we still in the Iron Age?

  1. Obviously we are in the Modern Age. Just as our Stone Age, Bronze and Iron Ages thought. It is not given to us to define our Age. It is our descendants who have that privilege. They may decide we are the Age of Destruction, or perhaps, given our obsession with social media, and Media in general, the Age of Distraction.

  2. Actually, we’re in the silicon age, which started shortly after 1947. ‘nuf said

  3. I recently had myy roof replaced after dealing with sevrral leaks over the years.
    It was a tough decision to invesst in a full replacement, but looking back, it was the
    best choice. The new roof has already improved my home’s
    insulation, and my energy bills are noticeably lower. I worked with a fantastic team
    from [roofing services], and they were professional, efficient, and transparent about
    costs. If anyone is debating between roof repairs and replacement,
    I highly recommend getting a professional inspection first.

    It can save you from unexpected expenses down the line.

    Has anyone here gone through a roof replacement recently?
    I’m curious about what factors you considered when choosing a roofing company.
    I did a lot of research before selecting [roofing services], and they exceeded my expectations.
    They explained the entire process clearly and helped me choose the best materials
    for my budget. Their team was punctual, respectful,
    and left my property spotless after the installation. Would love to hear how others made their decision when hiring
    a roofer!

    After a recent storm, I noticed several shingles missing from my roof.

    I wasn’t sure whether to repair the damage or consider a
    full replacement. Thankfully, I reached out to [roofing services], and they provided a thorough inspection. They explained that my roof was still structurally sound
    and only required minor repairs. Their honesty and professionalism were truly refreshing.
    Has anyone else had a similar experience where a roofing company provided an honest assessment rather than pushing for unnecessary work?

    I’ve always wondered how often a roof should be inspected.

    After reading this blog, I realized I’ve been neglecting regular roof maintenance for far too
    long. I scheduled an inspection with [roofing services], and they identified
    several issues I wouldn’t have noticed myself. Their team fixed everything quickly,
    and now I feel much more confident about my home’s condition. Do you all keep up with annual
    roof inspections, or do you wait until something goes
    wrong?

    Choosing the right roofing material was a challenge when I decided
    to replace my roof last summer. I wanted something durable, weather-resistant, and energy-efficient.
    After consulting with [roofing services],
    I went with architectural shingles, which balanced
    cost and longevity. The new roof looks fantastic, and I’ve noticed a
    big difference in my home’s temperature control. What materials have worked well for others in areas with unpredictable weather?

    Is anyone else considering eco-friendly roofing options?
    I recently switched to a sustainable roofing material recommended by [roofing services], and I’m so glad I did.
    Not only does it reduce my home’s environmental impact, but it also lowered my
    energy bills significantly. The installation was seamless, and
    their team provided excellent customer service.
    I’d love to hear about other eco-friendly upgrades you’ve made to your home!

    Replacing a roof can be overwhelming, especially when it comes to budgeting.
    I found that getting multiple quotes helped
    me feel more prepared. [Roofing services] offered the most transparent and competitive estimate.
    They broke down every cost clearly, which helped me avoid unexpected expenses.
    Has anyone else had success negotiating roofing costs
    or finding good financing options for a major home improvement project?

    After dealing with a persistent roof leak, I finally called [roofing services] for help.
    Their team was quick to respond and found the source
    of the problem within minutes. It turned out to be
    a damaged flashing near the chimney, which they repaired on the same day.

    I wish I’d contacted them sooner instead of attempting DIY fixes.
    Have you ever tried repairing a roof yourself, or do you
    always call a professional?

    How long did it take for your roofing project to be completed?
    My roof replacement took about two weeks, from inspection to final
    cleanup. The team at [roofing services] worked efficiently, even dealing with unexpected
    weather delays. Their commitment to quality really stood out.
    I’m curious how long similar projects have taken for others, especially in areas with frequent
    rain or snow.

    What should I look for when hiring a roofing contractor? I recently hired
    [roofing services], and their credentials made a huge difference in my decision.
    They were licensed, insured, and came highly recommended.
    I checked their past projects online, and the reviews were overwhelmingly
    positive. What are your must-have criteria when choosing
    a contractor for major home improvements?

    I used to think roof inspections were unnecessary until a small
    leak turned into major water damage in my attic.
    Since then, I’ve scheduled annual inspections with [roofing services], and it’s been worth every penny.
    They catch minor issues before they become serious problems.

    Do you have a maintenance routine for your roof, or do you wait until something goes wrong?

    Does anyone have tips for maintaining a roof during
    extreme weather? I live in an area with harsh winters, and
    ice buildup used to be a constant problem.
    After consulting with [roofing services], I installed better insulation and added a roof heating system.
    It’s been a game-changer. How do you prepare your home
    for extreme weather conditions?

    I never realized how much curb appeal a new roof
    could add to a home until I replaced mine. The transformation was stunning, and it boosted my home’s resale value significantly.

    I worked with [roofing services], and they helped me choose a style that complemented my house perfectly.
    Have you noticed how much a new roof can change a home’s appearance?

    Has anyone installed solar panels along with a roof replacement?
    I’m considering this upgrade and wondering if it’s cost-effective in the long run. [Roofing services] offers
    solar-ready roofing options, which seems like a smart way
    to combine two big home improvements. I’d appreciate any advice from
    those who’ve done both at once!

    I didn’t realize roof warranties could vary so
    much until I started researching. [Roofing services] offered a long-term warranty that
    covered both materials and labor, giving me peace of mind.
    What type of warranty did you choose when replacing
    your roof? I’d love to know what’s standard
    in the industry and what to watch out for.

    What’s been your biggest challenge when dealing with roof repairs?
    For me, it was finding a reliable contractor who didn’t try to upsell unnecessary services.
    Thankfully, [roofing services] provided a straightforward estimate
    and only recommended what was truly needed.
    It made the whole process much less stressful. How do you
    filter out unreliable contractors?

    my page: ventilation Installation.

  4. Great post! I’ve been consideribg paint proteection film for my car, and this helped me decide.
    The long-term benefits seerm worth thhe investment. Has anyone else tried it and nooticed
    a difference?
    I recently got a car wrap done, and I couldn’t be happier!
    It gave my carr a brand-new look. Highly recommend iit if you’re debating whethe to ggo
    for it.
    Thanks for sharing this! I didn’t realize how much ceramic coating caan do for a car.

    My biggest issue has always been rock chips, and
    this sounds like the perfect solution.
    I’ve been researching ceramic coating forr a while, and it’s so good too hear real ffeedback
    like this. Does anyone know how it holds up over time?
    I’m worried about durability.
    I just had my carr wrapped recently, and I can’t stop staring at it!
    It feels like driving a new car again. Plus, the
    wrap protects the paint underneath, which is a huge bonus.

    Great article! I’ve always wondered if PPF is woth the hype.
    It seems like it would save so much time on maintenance while keeping the car looking new.

    Anyone hhere tried it long-term?
    I used to spend hours waxing my car every feww weeks. After getting cerammic coating, I don’t have to anymore.
    Water just slides off, and it’s saved me so much effort!

    Really enjoyed tis read. I’m considering a ceramic coating for my car because I’ve
    heard it’s grsat for protection. Does anyone here recommend anyy spcific brands or installers?

    I’ve had paint protection fklm on my car foor about a
    yeaar now, and I can’t recommend it enough. The paint looks perfect.
    If you’re on the fence, just do it.
    This was super informative! I didn’t realize ceramic
    coating could block UV rays. I live in a hot area, so thiis
    might save my car’s paint from fading.
    I recently invested in cerqmic coating for my car,
    and I’m soo glad I did. It traansformed my car’s look completely, and I don’t stress
    over small scratches anymore.
    I’ve been dsbating between ceramic coating and regular waxing.
    Reading this post convinced me that long-term protectioln is the smarter choice.
    Anyone else made the switch?
    My car’s paint started showing tiny chips from highway driving, so
    I looked into PPF. Best decision ever. It’s like having an invisible shield
    on my car. Highky recommend it!
    Thanks for this post! I recenly wrapped my car, andd the custom
    design turned out bettr than I imagined. It’s also great knowing
    the paint underneath is protected.
    I’ve bbeen seeing a llot about ceramic coatings lately and
    wznted to knw if it’s worth it. After reading
    this, I thik I’ll give it a shot—it eems perfect for
    keeping a car clean without constant upkeep.
    This was suh a helpful read! I didn’t realize
    how much paint proteftion film helps prevemt scratches.
    I drive a lot, so this might be the solution I’ve been looking for.

    I wrapped my car last year, and it still looks incredible.
    It’s a fun way to custoimize your car while protecting
    the paint underneath. Definitely recommend it if you wan a change.

    For anyone debating PPF, just go for it! I had it applied to my car, and the difference
    is huge. It’s easier to clean, and I’ve had so many compliments.

    Really ingeresting post! I’m curious about how lokng ceramic coawtings actually last.
    Does anyone here have experience with them after a coyple of years?

    I was skeptical about PPF at first, but after tryging it, I’m a believer.
    My car looks spotless all the time, and I don’t tress about scratches or fading paint anymore.

    Has anyone tried cerqmic coattings for their car?
    I’ve bden thinking about upgrading my ride, and this post just cpnvinced me to look into it more seriously.

    I can’t recommend ceramic coating enough! It’s saved my car’s paint from so many
    small scratches and chips. Plus, it till looks perfect months
    later.
    I loved reading this! I had no dea ceramic coatings could make such a difference.
    I’m seriously considering it now foor long-term shine.

    I recently wrapped my car with a custom finish, and I get
    compliments everywhere I go. It’s such a fun way to stand out.

    If you’re considering it, I saay go for it!
    This was super helpful! I was on the fence about getting ceramic coating,
    but after reading this, I think it’s worth trying.
    Long-term protection sounds ljke a win-win.

    my blog; Vehicle ceramic protection

  5. I’ve been thinking about replacing my roof for a while now.
    This blog really heelped me understand the
    differeence betwewen roof repairs and replacements.

    I’ll definitely be contactibg a professional to get an assessment soon!
    This is really helpful. I didn’t realize how much the condition of your
    roof can affect your home’s overall efficiency.
    I’ve ben having some issues with leaks, so I think it’s time to
    consider repairs or a full replacement. I’ll definitely eep these
    tips iin mind!
    The roof replacement process was much smoother than I expected.
    It defiitely added value to my home andd saved me from dealing with cojstant repairs.
    I recommend getting a professional opinion if you’re unsure about ylur roof’s condition.
    I had noo idea that roof maintenance wwas so important!

    It’s definitely something I’ll pay more attention to moving forward.
    Thanks for thhe valuable information!
    It’s been really helpful tto read this blog to get a better understanding of my options.
    I’ll be scheduling a roof inspection tto see if repairs or
    a replacement is the bst route. Great advice!
    I’ve been wonderiing if it’s time for a new roof
    or if I can get away with some repairs. This article gave mme sime good insight on what to look
    for. I think I’ll be gettjng an expert’s opinion soon.
    It’s a tough decision, but this blog really helped me understand the pros and cons.
    I appreciate the advice on getting aan inspection before making a final decision.
    I didn’t know roof repairs could be done soo quickly.
    Thiss article has motivated me to schedule an appointment. Thanks for the
    helpful information!
    Has anyone else faced the diilemma of roof repairs versus replacement?

    This post made me realize how important itt is to consult
    a roofihg expert before making a decision.
    I always thought roo repairs were just about fixing leaks.
    I’ll bee booking an inspoection tto figure out what I need.
    Thanks for tthe clarity!
    After reading this, I understand that a small issue could lead
    to much bigger problems. I’ll definitely be
    getting my roof checked soon. Great avice here!

    I’ve beenn on the fence abbout whether to replace
    or repair my roof. The tips here helped me understand how to make a more informed decision. Thanks for sharing this valuable info.

    It’s good tto know that a 20-year-old roof is probably ready for a replacement.
    I’ll keepp that in mind as I move forward with my roof issues.

    I had a roof replacemdnt done last year, and I can’t stress enough how mucch better it feels.
    If anyone is hesitant about replacing their roof, I highly
    recopmmend considering it. It really makes a difference.

    What a helpful post! I’ll definitely follow your advice and have my
    roof inspected before making any decisions.
    I’ve been trying to delay repairs, but it’s becoming clear I need to addres the issues sooner rather than later.
    I’ll be contacting a professional soon.
    After reading this, I now understand how much more secure and efficient a new roof
    can be. Thanks for the helprul information—I think it’s time for an upgrade.

    I never considered roof maintenance until recently.
    I’ll definitely follow up with a roof inspection to
    see what’s needed.
    I’ve had some roofing issues for a while but wasn’t sure whether to replace or jst repair.

    This blog has really opened mmy eyes to the importance of getting a professional inspection. I thiink I’ll reach out to get some expert advice.

    This post makes iit seem like a much easier process than I expected.
    I’ll definitely keep this in mind when it’s timme to replace mine.
    Thanks for the helpful breakdown!
    I’ve been putting off roof repairs, but now I understand that addressing small issues early can save a lott
    in the future. I’ll be contacting a roofing
    professional to take a look at my roof.
    I’m going to make sure I get my roof inspected
    soon to avoid any bigger problems. This post really helpdd me understand whhy regular roof maintednance is so important.

    I recently had a major leak, and this post helped mme
    fiyure out whether I should repair oor replace my roof.
    I’ll be following up with a professional soon.
    This post really opened my eyes too how important roof repairs
    are. Thanks for the insightful information!
    I never thought about thhe long-term value of replacing a roof until now.
    It’s good to kow that a nnew roof can not only prevent leaks but also boost my home’s
    value. I’m definiitely considering my options now.

    Lookk into my homepage: Katherina

  6. I completely agree that home care is a great option for aging parents.
    Having trained caregivers ensures they stay safe at home.
    Have you looked into respite services?
    This post really resonate with me! When my father needed daily assistance, home care was tthe best choice.
    It gave us much-needed relief.
    Carting foor someone with Alzheimer’sis emotionally
    taxing, and professional help makes all the difference.

    I’veseen how memory care improve daily routines.

    Thank you for sharing this! Many people
    don’t realize how helpful home care services can be.
    It’s not just about mediucal support—it’s about independence too.

    I was hesitant about trying home care, but it turned out to be a lifesaver for my mom.
    It’s amazing how much support is available.
    Great post! Home care gives families flexibility, especially when balancing work.
    Have you explored respite care?
    Ican relate to this so much! Finding the right care provider took time,
    but now my dad has 24/7 support.
    This is such an important topic! Many seniors want to age att
    home, and live-in support makes that possible. Have
    yoou considered a professional caregiver?
    I completely understand the challenges of caring for a loved one.
    Having professional assistance can bee a great solution.
    So true! Palliative care at home makes such a difference.

    It’s not just about medical care, but aso
    emotional well-being.
    I had the same conceerns about bringing in a caregiver, but it turned out to be the best decision for our family.
    The right support mkes a huge impact.
    This article really highlights the need for trained professionals.
    Caring for someone with dementia is tough, and the
    right supprt is life-changing.
    Aging inn pllace is so important, and home care helps make it possible.
    I’ve seen firsthand hhow customized care improve daily life.

    Such a valuable discussion! Finding the right cae plan can be overwhelming,
    but home care provide great benefits.
    I never thought we’d need home care, but when my dad started struggling with daily tasks, it became clear that expert care was necessary.

    Thhis post makes a great point—dementia cawre at home ensures comfort for families.
    Have you looked into 24-hour caregivers?
    I appreciate this perspective! Many people don’t
    realize how affordable respite care can be. Even a few hours a week can be a big relief.

    Caring for a lkved onne at home is fulfilling, butt also challenging.

    I found that having a caregiver really helped.
    Thanks for sharing this! I waas in the same situation, and
    specialozed support made a positjve impact for my family
    member.
    A lot of people don’t realize that home care isn’t just for seniors—it’s grwat for chronic conditions
    too. It really helps with daily tasks.
    I love that this article touches on support for family caregivers.
    Taking a break is so important, and having professional herlp makes that possible.

    So true! Dementia care requires patience and training.
    That’s why home caregivers are so valuable.
    Having a trainned caregiver meas less stress for families.
    Have you explkred live-in options yet?
    Home care isn’t just about assistance—it’s aboout dignity.
    I’ve seen how a great caregicer can chanmge lives.
    I was skeptical about home services at first, but now I can’t imagine managing without it.

    It’s been a blessing for our family.

    Loook at my webpage Respite Support

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *