Brighton Law School blog

10

Pre-nups: How To Draft A Pre-nup In The Twilight Zone

At the Resolution National Conference 2015, the workshop on pre-nups was one of the more popular choices by far – nearly a quarter of delegates chose to attend. Perhaps this reflected a desire for stronger guidance on the drafting pre-nups during the twilight zone between Radmacher v Granatino [2010] UKSC 42 and the much awaited government response to the Law Commission’s consultation paper on pre-nups.

The panel of experts were top family lawyers with years of experience of drafting, contesting and defending pre-nups in divorce cases, including His Honour Judge Philip Waller CBE, Nicholas Cusworth QC (1 Hare Court), Philip Marshall QC, (1 King’s Bench Walk), William Longrigg (Charles Russell Speechlys) and James Carroll (Russell-Cooke).

Emma Wilkins of Practical Family Law set out the law as it currently stands following Radmacher v Granatino [2010]. The court should give effect to a nuptial agreement if it was freely entered into by each party; each party fully appreciated its implications when entering it; and it would be fair in the circumstances prevailing to uphold it. However, a nuptial agreement cannot oust the court’s jurisdiction and a judge’s broad discretion to apply the factors set out at section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973.

However she noted that the Radmacher test is subjective and so uncertain and in order to achieve certainty for clients, nuptial agreements would need to exclude the discretionary jurisdiction of the court. The Law Commission had suggested ways of removing the uncertainty through the adoption of QNAs (qualifying nuptial agreements) but the proposals were awaiting a response from the next government. The QNAs have strict criteria including contractual validity, full financial disclosure and a deadline of 28 days before any marriage.

So how to draft a prenup in the meantime? It was fascinating listening to the range of advice from ‘drafting a prenup as a qualifying QNA in order to future-proof it’ to advice from the bench that practitioners can only draft the contract according to current legislation – they would not get much sympathy for a document drafted with only a proposed Bill in mind! Nor were review clauses in favour with most of the panel on the basis that most people do not want to review a pre-nup when the marriage is going well and it weakens the original document.

Some of the panel wanted to include financial and non-financial provision for children yet to be born in order to make it a comprehensive document; others thought commitments to non-financial provision were best left to shared parenting plans rather than legal instruments!

Other elements of contract law pervaded the debate – what to do if duress could be involved; handling prenups for couples working and living for a time in other jurisdictions; how to enforce agreements in other jurisdictions. There was even a suggestion that arbitration clauses be included in pre-nups.

After an hour and a half of debate on pre-nups I truly felt that had just attended a revision session on Contract Law!

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Tracy Nuttall • 22/04/2015


Previous Post

Next Post

Comments

  1. Christine Elizabeth Blackledge 23/04/2015 - 9:57 am Reply

    Very interesting read, informative on pre-nups. I especially was interested about the mention of signing under duress, clients signing after the 28 days. This is due to pressure, some clients sign days before a wedding. Would like to see more blogs about this subject.

    Thank you,

  2. Evelynn 22/10/2023 - 4:33 pm Reply

    Want to replicate the excitement of a physical casi from the comfort of your home? https://slotscity.ua/ru/game-hall presents live dealer games that bring the game floor to your screen. Interact with professional dealers, place your bets, and enjoy the thrill of a real-time gaming experience. Discover the finest live games right here at Slotscity!

  3. orboneee 14/11/2023 - 9:10 am Reply

    I never knew about this information! very useful information Super Mario

  4. Yurri Murray 22/11/2023 - 2:42 pm Reply

    EZDrive MA is electronic toll software. With this device, you can pay your toll violations with E-ZPass or PaybyPlateMa. PaybyPlateMa

  5. Melisha Ray 31/01/2024 - 6:58 pm Reply

    MyKohlsCard allows customers with a Kohl’s Charge credit card to administer their accounts online.

  6. five nights at freddy’s 31/05/2024 - 7:36 am Reply

    Your information is extremely helpful, and I’d like to add that five nights at freddy’s is a fun and exciting way to spend time with loved ones and friends when you have some spare time.

  7. five nights at freddy’s 31/05/2024 - 7:44 am Reply

    Your information is extremely helpful, and I’d like to add that five nights at freddy’s is a fun and exciting way to spend time with loved ones and friends when you have some spare time.

  8. bscnews 14/06/2024 - 4:42 am Reply

    If you are going for best contents like I do, simply go to see this website all the time as it provides feature contents, thanks 슬롯사이트 순위

  9. outlookindiacom 14/06/2024 - 4:42 am Reply

    This is very helpful, especially for those who are planning to start their new career […] 에볼루션 바카라사이트

  10. neiljiohu 27/06/2024 - 4:36 am Reply

    市场上有许多网课代上服务机构,但其质量参差不齐。留学生应当通过多种途径对服务提供商进行全面了解,包括查看在线评价、询问使用过该服务的朋友或同学、研究提供商的网站和业务细节等。特别要注意的是,尽量选择那些在业内有一定知名度和良好口碑的网课代上 http://www.meeloun.com/wangkedaishang/ 机构。查看客户反馈和评价,了解其他用户的实际体验,可以帮助你判断该服务提供商是否可靠。此外,信誉良好的服务提供商通常会有详细的服务协议和保障措施,明确服务内容和双方责任,为客户提供一定的安全保障。

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published / Required fields are marked *

Skip to toolbar